Outsource and In-House signs pointing in opposite directions

Should a 250-Person Company Outsource IT or Keep It In-House?

For most 250-person companies, the answer is neither fully in-house nor fully outsourced. It is a split: keep IT ownership, priorities and business knowledge inside, and hand specialist, after-hours and security monitoring work to a managed service provider. That model is usually called co-managed IT.

The right split depends on how complex your systems are, how much hands-on support your sites need, and what your security and recovery obligations demand. This guide compares in-house, fully outsourced and co-managed IT for organisations of roughly 150 to 350 staff, across cost, security, continuity and accountability.

Key takeaways

  • At 250 staff, the real question is less “outsource or not” and more “which work should stay inside”.
  • Keep decisions in-house: priorities, budget, risk acceptance, vendor relationships and knowledge of how your systems fit together.
  • Outsource work that needs coverage and depth rather than business context: 24/7 monitoring, security monitoring, patching, backup operations and after-hours support.
  • Compare total cost, not a salary against a monthly fee.
  • Outsourcing security work does not outsource accountability for it.

Why isn’t this an either/or decision at 250 staff?

At 250 people, a business is large enough to need someone who owns IT, but rarely large enough to employ every specialist skill it relies on. Networking, security, cloud, backup, Microsoft 365 and end-user support are separate disciplines, and a small internal team ends up covering all of them at once.

That pressure is growing. The Future Skills Organisation projects Australia will be short 131,000 technology workers by 2030, so every internal hire is harder to find and harder to keep. We have written about the gap between what in-house IT teams are resourced to do and what infrastructure planning now requires.

Fully outsourcing removes the staffing problem but creates a different one: nobody inside the business owns IT decisions. That is why the practical answer for most organisations of this size sits in between.

What does in-house IT do well?

An internal team knows why your environment is the way it is: the integration that runs overnight, the application finance will not move off, the workaround everything else depends on. That knowledge is hard to transfer and slow to rebuild.

Pros:

  • Physical presence for hardware issues across offices, warehouses and production floors.
  • Deep knowledge of your line-of-business applications and internal workflows.
  • Direct control of priorities, with no contract between the request and the person doing the work.

Cons:

  • A small team cannot hold specialist depth across security, cloud, networking, backup and support at the same time.
  • Leave, illness and resignations create gaps, and round-the-clock cover is expensive to roster with a handful of people.
  • Recruitment takes time, carries agency and onboarding costs, and knowledge leaves when people do.

What does outsourced IT do well?

A managed service provider brings a team rather than an individual, and runs the same disciplines across many environments. What you are buying is coverage, repetition and specialist depth.

Pros:

  • Access to specialists in security, cloud, networking and support under one agreement.
  • 24/7 monitoring without rostering internal staff, with after-hours response available on the right service level.
  • Documented environments and knowledge shared across the provider’s team, so one resignation does not leave a gap.
  • A fixed monthly fee for an agreed scope, which makes the running cost easier to plan.

Cons:

  • The provider needs time to learn your line-of-business applications and workflows.
  • Work outside the agreed scope, such as projects and major changes, is usually quoted separately.
  • Hands-on work at your sites has to be arranged rather than walked over to.
  • Fully outsourced, nobody inside the business owns IT priorities, budget or risk decisions.

What does co-managed IT look like?

In a co-managed model, the internal team and the provider each own a defined part of the work, and the agreement says which is which.

Who usually owns each IT function in a co-managed model
FunctionUsually sits with
IT strategy, budget and roadmapInternal team
Business application ownership and vendor relationshipsInternal team
Risk acceptance and security decisionsInternal team
Day-to-day user supportShared
24/7 monitoring and alertingProvider
Security monitoring and detectionProvider
Patching and maintenanceProvider, with ownership agreed system by system
Backup operations and recovery testingProvider, governed internally
After-hours support and escalationProvider, where the agreement includes after-hours response

The test for each line is simple. Does doing it well depend on knowing your business, or on scale, coverage and repetition? The first stays. The second can move.

How do the costs compare?

Setting an internal salary against a provider’s monthly fee understates what in-house IT really costs and overstates what outsourcing costs. Compare the full annual cost on both sides.

Full annual cost of in-house IT compared with outsourced IT
In-house costsOutsourced costs
Salaries and superannuation (12% from 1 July 2025)Monthly managed services fee
Recruitment and agency feesOnboarding and transition
Training and certificationsProject work outside the agreed scope
Monitoring, security and management tool licencesLicences not included in the agreement
Leave and after-hours coverContract and exit terms
Management timeInternal time to govern the provider

Then add the costs you hope never to pay: downtime, a security incident, or a project that stalls because the team is busy keeping the lights on.

How the fee is structured matters as much as its size. A retainer that buys delivered work is different from one that only buys availability, and what your managed services retainer actually buys explains how to tell them apart.

Where does security sit in each model?

Security is where the gap between the models shows most. In a small internal team, security is one responsibility among many, competing with the ticket queue for time. Threat monitoring, vulnerability management and framework alignment need constant attention, and that time is hard to protect.

A provider can run monitoring, detection, endpoint protection and patching at a scale a small team cannot. But outsourcing the work does not outsource the accountability. Your organisation still decides which risks to accept and what to fix first when every security gap seems urgent.

The provider’s own security also becomes part of yours. Managed service providers often hold privileged access to their customers’ systems, which is why the Australian Cyber Security Centre publishes guidance on managing the risk that comes with managed service providers. Ask any provider how they address it. We have answered the ASD’s questions for managed service providers directly. If you supply larger organisations or government, also check the Essential Eight requirements your customers may pass down to you.

What about business continuity and disaster recovery?

An internal team can write a disaster recovery plan. It is much harder to test that plan regularly, keep infrastructure running in a second location, and carry out a recovery under pressure, all alongside daily support.

A provider can take on the operational side: replication, failover and test evidence. The decisions stay with you, including which systems come back first and how much data and downtime the business can tolerate. Evolution Systems delivers Disaster Recovery as a Service with automated failover, regular failover testing and geographically dispersed data centres.

How do you decide which model fits?

Lean more in-house if:

  • your operations depend on complex or proprietary systems that need daily hands-on attention
  • you run several sites that need frequent physical support
  • you do significant internal software development
  • IT is part of how you compete

Lean more outsourced if:

  • most of your systems are standard or cloud-based
  • you need 24/7 coverage you cannot roster internally
  • your security or compliance obligations exceed what your team can resource
  • you are growing and need capacity without a new hiring cycle each time

Choose co-managed if you have an IT manager or a small team worth keeping, plus gaps in coverage, security depth or recovery capability they cannot close alone. At 250 staff, that describes most organisations.

Comparison: in-house, outsourced and co-managed IT

In-house, fully outsourced and co-managed IT compared for a 250-person company
CapabilityIn-houseFully outsourcedCo-managed
24/7 monitoringHard to roster with a small teamIncludedProvider
Specialist security depthLimited by headcountProvider's teamProvider's team, internal ownership
Knowledge of your businessStrongBuilds over timeStrong
On-site presenceImmediateArrangedInternal team on site, provider for escalation
Cost predictabilitySalaries are predictable; gaps and turnover are notFixed fee for an agreed scopeFixed fee plus a smaller internal team
Ownership of IT decisionsInternalWeak unless actively governedInternal
Scaling for growthRequires hiringAdjusts within the agreementAdjusts within the agreement
Tested disaster recoveryPossible, hard to sustainRun by the providerRun by the provider, governed internally

How Evolution Systems works with organisations of this size

Evolution Systems has provided managed IT to Australian organisations since 2000, with a 92% client retention rate and ISO 27001 certification since 2016. We work with mid-market organisations, including those with their own IT team.

Our managed IT services work either way. We can run IT end to end, or work alongside an internal team that keeps ownership while we take monitoring, security and recovery, with extended or after-hours response if you need it. That is what Personalised IT means in practice: the scope is shaped around your environment, not a fixed tier.

If you are weighing up the right split for your organisation, talk to us about managed IT.

FAQs

Is outsourced IT cheaper than in-house IT for a 250-person company?

Not always, and comparing a salary with a monthly fee will mislead you either way. Compare full annual cost: salaries, super, recruitment, training, tools and leave cover on the in-house side, against the managed services fee, onboarding, out-of-scope work and the internal time needed to govern a provider. For most organisations of this size, the better value comes from outsourcing the coverage and specialist work that is most expensive to staff, not everything.

How many IT staff does a 250-person company need?

There is no reliable ratio, because it depends on how many sites you run, how complex your systems are and how much you outsource. A more useful question is which roles must sit inside the business. That is usually someone who owns IT priorities, budget and vendors, plus enough hands-on capacity for on-site and business-specific support. The specialist and after-hours work around them can come from a provider.

What is co-managed IT?

Co-managed IT is an arrangement where an internal IT team and a managed service provider share responsibility for the environment, each owning a defined part of the work. The internal team usually keeps strategy, priorities and business systems. The provider usually takes monitoring, security operations and specialist escalation, plus after-hours response where the agreement includes it. The split is written into the agreement so nothing falls between the two.

Does outsourcing IT mean losing control of priorities?

It should not. Priorities, budget and risk decisions stay with your organisation, and the provider works to an agreed scope, service levels and escalation paths. Regular service reviews are where you check delivery against those terms and reset priorities.

What security standards should a managed IT provider work to?

At a minimum, look for independently certified security management, such as ISO 27001, and practical alignment with the ASD Essential Eight. Evolution Systems has been ISO 27001 certified since 2016 and aligns with the Essential Eight. Also ask any provider how they control their own privileged access to your systems, because their security becomes part of yours.

What happens outside business hours with a managed provider?

It depends on the service level you choose, so check it in writing: what is monitored, how a critical issue is raised, and who responds and when. At Evolution Systems, monitoring runs 24/7 for managed services and private cloud customers, and the service desk operates during business hours. Under the standard agreement, a Priority 1 or 2 alert outside business hours is picked up at 9am the next business day. Our Extended Business Hours (7am to 7pm weekdays) and After Hours (24/7) service levels extend live response.

When does fully in-house IT make sense?

When IT is central to how you compete, when you do substantial internal software development, or when your operations need constant hands-on support across several sites. Even then, a provider can still fill specific gaps such as after-hours monitoring or specialist security work.

Let's see how we can personalise your IT

Evolution Systems is ISO 27001 Certified

Information Security ISO 27001 Certification